Seeking Persephone by Sarah Eden was recommended as a Christian, clean, character-building book. I was excited because I was recently lamenting at the lack of Christian, clean, character-building books and wondered why there aren’t more of them. Good News for Little Hearts is a good resource (even these books are more didactic than story telling), but there really aren’t many great Christian fiction books that point to the gospel. I found a copy of Seeking Persephone at the library and decided to pick it up. Published in 2008, I think the new movie is why it's being talked about today.
Bottom line upfront: This book is neither Christian nor character-building.
It’s just another in a long line of preposterous romance novels that lead
people away from Christian love, marriage, and contentment. Think Pride &
Prejudice, Wuthering Heights, or Little Women, as it clearly draws
heavily from all three. Hidden in the details is the fact that the author is a Mormon.
The book is a loose retelling of the Greek myth of
Persephone and Hades, set in 1805 England. The only remotely Christian thing
about it is that it states that Greek myths are simply myths while the Bible is
true. No depth beyond that is present. A pastor of an unknown denomination (presumably
Anglican) makes a house call, but it is only to invite the newlyweds to a
dance.
The book departs far from the teachings of the Bible by
emphasizing that the goal of the wife is that the husband would “respect” her.
The Bible is clear that the goal of the husband is to love his bride as Christ loved the church, sacrificing for her and seeing her transformed from
one degree of glory to another. The theology of marriage is very poorly framed
and a loose understanding of English dowries fills the missing details.
There is a very poorly written suspenseful section that is
based on an outlandishly improbable plan. In reality the plan would have failed,
but that would have robbed the main character of the opportunity to yell, “Bacon!”
In the middle of the emergency the main character is actively having epiphanies
and deep thoughts which breaks the suspense and realism. Clearly the author has
never been in the midst of a real emergency.
The resolution of the crisis is hasty and vengeful which will teach readers to hurt those who hurt them, rather than
show the love of Christ which calls us to pray for and love our enemies. In
another place a character declares that he needed to be lied to. Both of these
are direct contradictions to the teaching of Christ. A minor character is also
encouraged in their interest and investigation of “haunted castles.”
*Spoiler Alert* The book has a section where they try to
decide what to do with a pack of ravenous mongrel dogs. I said out loud, “Shoot
them in the face!” which is the only reasonable response to animals that are endangering
the human residents of the fictitious castle grounds. Instead, another
impossibly untenable plan is invented so the “wolves” can hunt their own
section of the forest away from the human inhabitants. If the book went longer,
I would expect one of the younger siblings of Persephone to end up being a meal.
Whether this was a ploy to force animal rights on the reader or just poor writing
never materialized.
Victimhood is also foisted upon the audience and how unfair
life is for people who seemingly deserve better. Both husband and wife
are victims of their upbringings, the “toxic” mother also ends up being a victim,
and many of the children are victims. Persephone blatantly dishonors her father
for his lack of prowess in the midst of hard decisions. The constant victimhood
is the worst part of the book as God calls us to be more than conquerors
through Christ who loved us. When you make someone a victim you cut them off
from the gospel, so it is no surprise that there is no gospel in this book.
Since there is no gospel, we wouldn’t expect any fruit of
the gospel. The main character and his best friend are constantly tearing each
other down, and it’s a continual theme throughout the book that is never
resolved. Not only is a bad for character, it’s exhausting to read their
constant jabs at each other.
Overall, I very much do not recommend this book because of
its unchristian teachings. Do not let your daughters read it alone without
discussion. From just a readability standpoint, the conflict, escalation, and
resolution are also very poor. If you do read it, you’ll be helped by a refresher
of the Persephone and Hades story before you read Seeking Persephone, as
it will make many details make sense. Though, these are meticulously (you might
say agonizingly) explained at the end of the book.
If you’re looking for something in this style that honors Christ,
while it has been a long time since I read it, I would recommend Love Comes
Softly by Janette Oke.












































